There is much discrepancy when one begins to compare the tonal differences that a herringbone top purfle can make on a guitar.  Various luthiers have different opinions on what these tonal differences are, some going as far as stating there is absolutely no difference in sound between a herringbone and non-herringbone guitar.

With the recent arrival of a few D1HA models from Collings, we were presented with the perfect opportunity to compare this particular feature side-by-side on two otherwise identically spec'd instruments.

We believe our recording speaks for itself... there certainly is a difference in tone!!!  The guitars tested were a Collings D1HA and a Collings D1A.  Same tonewoods and bracing... the only difference between these guitars is the herringbone.

Now you decide...